About Fat Witch Bakery

From one fabulous brownie recipe, a bakery was born. Fat Witch’s edible inventory now includes 15 varieties and counting. She has cast a spell on taste buds around the world, and welcomes sweet teeth near and far into her store inside NYC’s Chelsea Market.

Fat Witch turns old-fashioned recipes into modern day irresistible treats for the gourmet palate. She bakes from scratch, in small quantities, and with natural ingredients available in supermarkets. You can make your own “witches” at home using witch mixes and a brownie cookbook.

8 thoughts on “About Fat Witch Bakery”

  1. I recently fell in love with a Fat Witch Baby at the Amas Theater Awards Celebration and realized I wanted to share the magic with 60 members of the http://www.WomensFoodAlliance.com …an organization that I founded in September 2013. Please let me know who owns your company since I’m very anxious to do a TASTING in northeast Florida (Jacksonville area) for our women in the hospitality and food industry. With deep appreciation, Leigh Cort

    1. Hi Leigh, thank you for reaching out to us! Of course, we’re always interested in foodies. Please call 212-807-1335

  2. LOVE these brownies……one comment though….PLEASE make a cream cheese swirl brownie, and a peanut butter filled one….those would make a lot of people so happy….especially ME!! Tried to order others from other places and threw them in the trash, just don’t have the intense flavor of yours!!!!

    1. We’re thrilled you like our brownies. We do one with peanut butter swirls and toss roasted peanuts on top in the store. Follow us @fatwitch on Twitter and we’ll let you know when we have them in the store in Chelsea. Do you live in NYC? If not, I appreciate your suggestion and we will consider the peanut butter one for shipping. Honestly won’t happen until 2015, though. Cream Cheese Swirl – we can do that for the store, but not for shipping.

      Thanks for taking the time to write us!

  3. No, I live in metro Atlanta. You’re brownies are incredible, and would love an opportunity to be able to order the peanut butter ones to be shipped….please keep us posted on that. Absolutely love cream cheese swirl, too bad I can’t get those as well….but maybe in time you would be able to…I’ll keep watching for sure.

    1. Thanks, Sandra! Well, you can buy our brownie mix online and then swirl in some softened to room temperature cream cheese using a fork. We have our own kind of version (cream cheese in the middle) in our first cookbook if you’re up for baking your own!

    1. Hi Janet, wrapped Witches available on our website stay fresh 5-7 days in a cool room. Do not place them near a source of heat, such as electronic equipment or a window that gets sun or a space with excessive moisture. In the refrigerator they will last 7-21 days depending on the efficiency of your refrigerator. You can put them in the freezer and they will last up to 3 months, depending on the efficiency of your freezer. We suggest storing them in zip-lock bags. Some people like to eat them straight from the freezer without thawing. At our store inside Chelsea Market, we also have unwrapped Witches. These stay fresh 1-2 days. You can also refrigerate or freeze. We suggest storing unwrapped Witches in a plastic wrap and/or zip-lock bags.

Comments are closed.